Summary:
Middlebury, Vermont, has four schools—two elementary schools, one middle school and one high school—with 1,428 students across the elementary-to-high-school years. VTCAP results are available for 2024–2025 and 2025–2026, and the latest results show a clear difference across the grade span: Mary Hogan School was above its state benchmarks in six of seven reported tests, while Middlebury Union Middle School was above in three of seven.
Mary Hogan School stands out most consistently: its grade 4 ELA result was 78%, compared with 63% statewide, a 15-point advantage, and it was above the state in five other reported tests. Middlebury Union High School had strong grade 9 results—62% in ELA versus 50% statewide and 52% in math versus 44%—but its grade 11 science result was 44%, below the state’s 48%. The middle school’s sharpest shortfall was grade 8 ELA: 48% versus 57%, or 10 points below the state. Weybridge Elementary School’s 2025–2026 test results are suppressed, so it cannot be placed in this achievement comparison.
Results have shifted rather than improving steadily: Mary Hogan grade 4 ELA rose 19 points from 59% to 78%, while middle school grade 8 ELA fell 17 points from 65% to 48%. Across 13 results comparable across both years, the average state-relative margin narrowed from 6 points above the state to 2 points above. SchoolDigger’s latest ratings are four stars for Mary Hogan and the high school, and three for the middle school; its statewide percentiles over three years were 82, 75 and 71 for Mary Hogan, 87, 67 and 73 for the high school, and 48, 72 and 52 for the middle school. Student-teacher ratios are 16.9 at Mary Hogan, 12.8 at the middle school and 12.4 at the high school. As context, free/reduced lunch eligible figures for 2024–2025 were 42% at Mary Hogan, 35% at the middle school, 37% at the high school and 17% at Weybridge; these figures do not explain achievement differences.
Thank you for your feedback!