Summary:
This analysis covers three elementary schools in zip code 79835 (Canutillo, TX), all serving grades PK through 5 within the Canutillo Independent School District (Isd), an area characterized by high levels of economic disadvantage.
Canutillo Elementary is the clear academic leader, consistently earning a 4-star rating and ranking in the top 30% of Texas elementary schools. It significantly outperforms both the district and state averages in core subjects like 3rd-grade Reading and Math. In contrast, Deanna Davenport Elementary has the highest level of economic disadvantage (85.81% free/reduced lunch) and the highest per-student spending ($15,480), yet it holds the lowest academic rankings (2-star, 36th percentile). This starkly illustrates that spending does not directly correlate with performance. Jose H Damian Elementary sits in the middle, but shows a notable strength in 5th-grade Mathematics, where it outperforms both the district and state averages.
A key takeaway is that Canutillo Elementary is an outlier within its district, suggesting unique leadership or instructional strategies driving its success. Meanwhile, Deanna Davenport Elementary shows a positive upward trend in its state ranking, improving from the 27th percentile to the 36th percentile over recent years, indicating recent efforts may be yielding results. The data also reveals highly variable performance on Spanish-language STAAR tests, with Canutillo Elementary showing strong results in 3rd-grade Spanish Math, while Deanna Davenport Elementary had a critical failure point with 0% proficiency in 3rd-grade Spanish Reading and Math in a recent year.
Thank you for your feedback!