Summary:
This analysis examines three middle schools in the 78723 zip code of Austin, Texas, serving grades 5-8 or 6-8, an area characterized by high economic disadvantage where all schools report over 64% of students qualifying for free or reduced lunch.
The schools present a complex picture of contrasting strengths. Sadler Means Ywla is a standout for advanced coursework, with 94.59% of its students scoring proficient on the English I Reading EOC and 74.36% on the Algebra I EOC, dramatically exceeding both Austin Independent School District (Isd) and state averages. However, this success creates a "two-schools-in-one" dynamic, as its 6th-grade math proficiency was just 4.35%, and it has the highest dropout rate in the zip code at 4.1%. Austin Achieve Middle is the only school showing consistent improvement in its state ranking, moving from the 14th to the 13th percentile, and maintains a very low dropout rate of 0.6% despite having the largest enrollment (669 students) and highest student-teacher ratio (21.3:1). General Marshall Middle is the most aligned with district averages, has the lowest economic disadvantage rate (64.04%), and a moderate student-teacher ratio of 15.4:1.
A critical red flag is the "zero percent" anomaly in 8th-grade mathematics, where both Austin Achieve Middle and General Marshall Middle reported 0% proficiency in recent years, indicating a systemic failure at that grade level. Spending also varies dramatically, with Sadler Means Ywla spending $17,236 per student—57% more than Austin Achieve Middle ($10,979)—yet achieving lower overall proficiency for most students. This data reveals a landscape where schools face significant challenges, with each showing unique strengths and weaknesses that parents must weigh carefully.
Thank you for your feedback!