Summary:
In zip code 78621 (Elgin, TX), there are two middle schools serving grades 5-8 within the Elgin Independent School District (Isd), a district ranked in the 5th percentile statewide, where over 80% of students face significant socioeconomic hardship.
Elgin Middle (grades 7-8) stands out for a few bright spots despite overall low scores. Its Algebra I proficiency rate of 42% in 2024-2025 nearly matches the state average, suggesting effective acceleration for some students. The school also shows a slight upward ranking trend and a lower dropout rate (0.4%) than the district. In contrast, Elgin Intermediate (grades 5-6) faces more severe challenges, with only 2.5% of 5th graders proficient in Science and roughly 9% proficient in Math—about one-fifth of the state average. Elgin Middle benefits from a lower student-teacher ratio (17.3:1) and higher per-student spending ($10,389) compared to Elgin Intermediate (21.7:1 and $8,613), yet both schools consistently score 20-40 points below state averages in core subjects.
The most critical takeaway is the "5th Grade Wall" at Elgin Intermediate, where foundational math and science scores are the lowest in the dataset, indicating a systemic crisis likely tied to poverty and early education gaps. The "Algebra I Anomaly" at Elgin Middle reveals a two-tier math system: a struggling general population and a successful accelerated group. Overall, the data suggests that while Elgin Middle shows some promise, both schools require comprehensive, district-wide reform rather than isolated fixes to address deeply rooted challenges.
Thank you for your feedback!