Summary:
In zip code 78209 of San Antonio, Texas, there are two middle schools serving grades 6 through 8: Alamo Heights J H and Garner Middle, which belong to the Alamo Heights Independent School District (Isd) and the North East Independent School District (Isd), respectively.
These two schools present a stark contrast in performance and resources. Alamo Heights J H is a standout, earning a 4-star rating and ranking in the top 16th percentile statewide, with strong academic scores well above state averages. In comparison, Garner Middle struggles with a 1-star rating and ranks in the bottom 13th percentile, with proficiency rates significantly below state averages. Interestingly, Garner Middle spends about $3,100 more per student and has a lower student-to-teacher ratio than Alamo Heights J H, yet its academic outcomes are much lower, highlighting that factors beyond funding, such as the high poverty rate at Garner Middle (82% of students qualify for free or reduced lunch versus 23% at Alamo Heights J H), play a critical role in school performance.
A key takeaway is that both schools share a notable weakness in 7th-grade math, with proficiency rates far below the state average, suggesting a systemic issue in the area. However, advanced coursework like Algebra I acts as a great equalizer: both schools achieve proficiency rates well above the state average, showing they effectively prepare top-tier students. Additionally, Garner Middle underperforms its own district averages by 15-25 percentage points, indicating its challenges are school-specific rather than district-wide. For parents, Alamo Heights J H offers a high-achieving environment, while Garner Middle, despite resource advantages, faces significant academic hurdles tied to its student demographics.
Thank you for your feedback!