Summary:
This analysis examines three middle schools (Grades 6-8) located in the 78155 zip code of Seguin, Texas, which are split between the Seguin Independent School District (Isd) and the Navarro Independent School District (Isd).
Navarro J H is the clear standout, ranking in the 64th percentile statewide and significantly outperforming the two Seguin ISD schools across nearly every academic metric. For example, its average reading proficiency (57.2%) and math proficiency (37.1%) meet or exceed state averages, while Briesemeister Middle (19th percentile) and Jim Barnes Middle (10th percentile) fall well below. A key indicator of advanced programming is Algebra I acceleration: 91.21% of Navarro J H 8th graders taking the exam were proficient, compared to 80.33% at Briesemeister and just 58.49% at Jim Barnes. The data also reveals a strong correlation between socioeconomic status and performance, with Navarro J H having a much lower free/reduced lunch rate (41.64%) than Briesemeister (75.06%) and Jim Barnes (70.34%). Notably, spending per student does not predict success, as Briesemeister spends the most ($9,866) but achieves the second-lowest scores, while Navarro J H spends a middle amount ($9,427) for the best results.
A concerning trend across all three schools is a dramatic drop in math proficiency from 6th to 7th grade, far exceeding the state average decline. For instance, Jim Barnes Middle sees 6th-grade math at 19.26% plummet to just 3.77% in 7th grade, suggesting a systemic curriculum or instruction issue. While the Seguin ISD schools show stagnation or decline in state rankings, Navarro J H is on a clear upward trajectory, improving from the 60th to the 64th percentile. For parents, the choice of district is critical, as Navarro Independent School District (Isd) (ranked 250th in Texas) provides a dramatically different educational experience than Seguin Independent School District (Isd) (ranked 761st), even within the same zip code.
Thank you for your feedback!