Summary:
This analysis examines 15 elementary schools in the 75150 zip code of Mesquite, Texas, serving grades PK-5 (with one charter serving through grade 8), where an average of 81.5% of students are economically disadvantaged, and overall performance is below the state median.
The clear academic standout is Motley Elementary, which ranks in the 73rd percentile and earns a 4-star rating, achieving top scores in 5th Grade Math (81.48% proficient) and Reading (70.37%) despite 90.57% of its students being economically disadvantaged. Austin Elementary is a consistent high performer, ranking in the 70th percentile with the area's lowest poverty rate (66.34%), excelling in 4th Grade Math (64.81%) and 5th Grade Reading (66.67%). Larry G Smith Elementary (Dallas ISD) is a standout for its bilingual program, with Spanish-language STAAR scores often exceeding English averages, achieving this despite a 95.45% economic disadvantage rate—the highest in the area. In contrast, Range Elementary has sharply declined from the 62nd percentile (3-star) to the 22nd percentile (1-star), with scores now below district averages. The only charter, Trinity Basin Preparatory - Mesquite, shows a "middle school slump," with 7th Grade Math proficiency dropping to 0% in 2025-2026.
Key takeaways include that poverty is not destiny—schools like Motley and Larry G Smith prove high performance is possible despite extreme disadvantage. Bilingual programs at Tosch Elementary and Larry G Smith show promise, with Spanish test scores often exceeding state averages. However, spending does not guarantee results: Trinity Basin spends the most ($14,465 per student) but ranks in the 12th percentile, while Shands Elementary spends the least ($8,574) and ranks in the 45th percentile. Across all schools, Science scores are a universal weak point, with 5th Grade Science proficiency often below 20%, signaling a need for improved curriculum. The Mesquite ISD (27th percentile) governs most schools, while Dallas ISD (54th percentile) oversees Larry G Smith.
Thank you for your feedback!