Summary
Stewart Elementary in Lubbock, TX, is a PK-5 school in the Lubbock Independent School District serving 369 students in a high-poverty area, where about 88% of students qualify for free or reduced lunch. The school has experienced a dramatic and recent performance collapse, dropping from the 63rd percentile statewide in 2022-2023 to the 20th percentile in 2025-2026—a much steeper decline than nearby schools like Wester Elementary, which serves a nearly identical student population but ranks in the 81st percentile. This volatility is unique to Stewart, as its peers have not seen such a sharp fall from a position of relative strength.
Math performance at Stewart is highly inconsistent by grade level, creating a "tale of two subjects." In 2023-2024, 4th graders achieved a remarkable 71.15% proficiency rate in math, far exceeding the district average of 43.81%, but just one year later, the same cohort as 5th graders scored only 38.6%. This pattern suggests success may be tied to specific teachers or strategies not replicated across all grades, unlike top-performing nearby schools like Miller Elementary, which shows consistent strength across all grades. The most significant academic weakness is 5th-grade math, where only 25.58% of students were proficient in 2025-2026, a staggering 22 percentage points below the district average and the lowest among all nearby schools for that subject and grade.
Stewart’s per-student spending ($9,768 in 2020-2021) is higher than that of Miller ($9,184) and comparable to Whiteside Elementary ($9,779), yet its academic outcomes are drastically lower. This underperformance despite high spending contrasts sharply with Miller, which achieves top-quartile results with lower spending. The recent decline is broad-based, affecting nearly all student subgroups, with African American students ranking in the 0th percentile statewide in 2025-2026—a catastrophic collapse from the 65th percentile just two years prior. The success of nearby Wester, which proves high poverty does not have to dictate low performance, provides a clear benchmark for what is possible within the same district and neighborhood.
Thank you for your feedback!