Summary:
The Eagle Mt-Saginaw Independent School District (Isd) serves four high schools for grades 9-12, including three large comprehensive campuses and one smaller alternative school, offering a range of academic environments for families in the area.
Boswell High School stands out as the district's top performer, boasting the highest state ranking (58th percentile), a 98% graduation rate, and leading scores in Biology, English II Reading, and U.S. History. In contrast, Chisholm Trail High School and Saginaw High School perform similarly, ranking in the 45th and 44th percentiles respectively, with Saginaw showing a slightly higher graduation rate (97.6% vs. 96.2%) but a higher percentage of students on free/reduced lunch. Elmer C Watson High School is a clear outlier: it has the lowest enrollment (90 students), the highest per-student spending ($16,935), and the smallest class sizes (8.8:1 ratio), yet it ranks in the 10th percentile with dramatically lower test scores and a 1.9% dropout rate, indicating it serves a specialized at-risk population.
A critical district-wide weakness is Algebra I proficiency, where all schools fall well below the state average of 54%, with Boswell's 34% being the highest among the traditional schools. Boswell excels in humanities, meeting or exceeding state averages in English and U.S. History, while Chisholm Trail deserves recognition for its exceptionally low 0.1% dropout rate, the best in the district. Overall, families should consider Boswell for strong academic outcomes, while Watson offers a highly resource-intensive environment for students needing alternative support.
Thank you for your feedback!