Summary:
This analysis examines seven middle schools in McAllen, Texas, serving grades 6-8 (with one exception), spread across the McAllen Independent School District (Isd) and the Sharyland Independent School District (Isd), revealing a wide range of academic performance and school characteristics.
Morris Middle stands out as the clear top performer, consistently ranking in the top 10% of Texas middle schools with exceptional STAAR scores in Reading and Mathematics. Michael E Fossum Middle is a strong second, also earning high marks. At the other end, Travis Middle faces the most challenges, with the highest percentage of economically disadvantaged students and the lowest state ranking, despite having the highest per-student spending. De Leon Middle and Brown Middle also rank in the bottom half, while Cathey Middle and Sharyland North J H perform in the middle range. A key takeaway is that higher spending does not guarantee better results, as the top-spending school (Travis) has the lowest outcomes, while lower-spending schools like Fossum and Morris lead the district.
The most remarkable finding is the universal excellence in Algebra I, where all seven schools achieved proficiency rates of 94% or higher, far exceeding the state average of 54%. This suggests a highly effective, city-wide approach to advanced math. However, there is a significant performance gap within McAllen ISD itself, with a difference of over 50 percentile points between its top school (Morris) and its lowest (Travis). For parents, this means that while the district overall performs well, individual school choice is critical, with Morris and Fossum offering the strongest academic track records, particularly in core subjects.
Thank you for your feedback!