Summary:
The three public schools in the Cotulla Independent School District (Isd) serve 1,083 students across elementary, middle, and high school grades in a community where over 84% of students face economic disadvantage, a challenge that shapes all academic outcomes.
For parents, the standout school is Frank Newman Middle, which excels in advanced math: its Algebra I proficiency rates of 70.51% and 74.39% far exceed state averages and are the highest in the district. However, this success does not carry over to general math, where 6th-grade proficiency is only 22.35%. In contrast, Cotulla High School shines in student retention with a 94.8% graduation rate and a 0.8% dropout rate, despite test scores below state averages. Ramirez-Burks Elementary shows inconsistent performance, with 4th-grade math proficiency (50.77%) more than double that of 5th-grade math (22.86%), suggesting success depends heavily on the teacher or student cohort. All three schools have favorable student-teacher ratios, with Cotulla High School at 8.6:1, Frank Newman Middle at 10.9:1, and Ramirez-Burks Elementary at 11.6:1, and spending per student ranges from $13,803 at the elementary to $17,591 at the high school.
A key takeaway is the "Algebra I Paradox": while Frank Newman Middle achieves top-tier Algebra I scores, Cotulla High School's Algebra I proficiency is just 7.69%, indicating a major curriculum or instruction gap between schools. Across the district, test scores lag 10-30 percentage points behind state averages, especially in math and science, despite high per-student spending. This suggests that financial resources alone cannot overcome the systemic challenges tied to poverty, making the district's strong graduation rates and low dropout rates at the high school particularly noteworthy achievements.
Thank you for your feedback!