Summary:
The city of Carthage, Texas, is served by seven schools across two districts: the Carthage Independent School District (Isd), which operates five schools from Pre-K through 12th grade, and the Panola Charter School district, which runs two high schools. The standout performer is Panola Early College High School, ranked in the 99th percentile statewide with 100% proficiency in several core subjects, despite having the lowest per-student spending ($6,686) and a high student-teacher ratio. In stark contrast, Panola Charter School is the most challenged, ranking in the 21st percentile with a 5.1% dropout rate and 0% proficiency in Algebra I, yet it spends the most per student ($18,237).
Within the Carthage ISD, performance is more consistent but varies by subject. Carthage J H shows a fascinating split: its 8th graders achieve exceptional Algebra I proficiency (87.5%), but only 11% of 7th graders are proficient in grade-level math, well below the state average. Carthage High School posts a solid 93.8% graduation rate and a low 0.7% dropout rate, while elementary schools like Carthage Pri and Libby Elementary serve younger students with moderate test scores. The district's free/reduced lunch rates range from 45.99% to 60.62%, indicating a significant level of economic disadvantage across the community.
The key takeaway for parents is that school choice in Carthage dramatically impacts outcomes. The Panola Charter district offers a high-risk, high-reward scenario: a world-class early college option and a struggling alternative. Meanwhile, the Carthage ISD provides a more traditional pipeline with generally average performance, though math proficiency for the majority of middle school students is a notable weakness. The data clearly shows that higher spending does not guarantee better results, as the most expensive school is the lowest-performing, while the most efficient school achieves top-tier success.
Thank you for your feedback!