Summary:
Zip code 57783 includes six schools in Spearfish, from elementary through high school: three elementary schools, one middle school and two high schools, all in Spearfish School District 40-2. The clearest current academic results are for Creekside Elementary and Spearfish Middle School, which are both above state averages in their reported all-grades results. The strongest available current academic results are at Creekside, especially in math: its result is 17 percentage points above the state.
Creekside is the clearest academic standout: in 2025–2026, it scored 58% in ELA and 61% in math, compared with 49% and 44% statewide. It leads Spearfish Middle by 6 points in ELA and 14 in math; the middle school also exceeds the state, by 3 points in each subject. However, the middle school’s eighth-grade science result was 4 points below the state. Spearfish High School stands out for graduation: its 97% rate is 9 points above the state, while its ACT math result is 7 points above the state, ELA is essentially even, and science is 2 points below. Current test scores are not supplied for West Elementary or Mountain View Elementary; the Academy’s scores are state-suppressed and unknown.
Results have shifted differently by school: Creekside improved in both reported all-grades subjects from 2024–2025, with a particularly sharp rise in math, while Spearfish Middle declined in both; eighth-grade science at the middle school fell 11 points. SchoolDigger gives Creekside four stars, ranks it 56th of 203 schools and places it at the 72nd percentile. Creekside’s student–teacher ratio is 15.4:1, compared with 14.8:1 at Spearfish Middle; their free/reduced lunch eligible shares were 23% and 18%, respectively, in 2024–2025. These are useful context, not explanations for achievement differences.
Thank you for your feedback!