Summary:
Schools in ZIP code 57730 comprise three schools in Custer School District 16-1, serving students from prekindergarten through grade 12: Custer Elementary (269 students), Custer Junior High (101), and Custer High School (272). The clearest shared academic strength is math: Elementary and Junior High both exceed state results, with the advantage substantially larger at Elementary.
Custer Elementary stands out most in the latest all-grades results, with 69% proficient in math—25 percentage points above the state—and 57% in ELA, 8 points above. Custer Junior High is also above state in both subjects: 58% in math, 14 points above, and 53% in ELA, 4 points above. Still, strong overall scores mask ELA trouble spots: third grade at Elementary is 8 points below state, and eighth grade at Junior High is 7 points below. Custer High School has mixed grade 11 ACT results: math is 6 points above state, while ELA and science are each about 1 point below. Its graduation rate is 92%, 5 points above state.
Recent results are mixed: the average ELA advantage for Elementary and Junior High narrowed from 14 percentage points in 2024–2025 to 6 in 2025–2026, while their average math advantage grew from 16 to 20 points. Elementary math improved by 9 points year over year; Junior High ELA fell by 13. SchoolDigger gives Elementary 4 stars and ranks it 34th of 203 schools (83rd percentile), and gives Junior High 4 stars, ranking it 32nd of 151 (79th percentile). High School is 2 stars, 66th of 130 (49th percentile), down from the 86th percentile the prior year. Attendance also differs: chronic absenteeism is 7% at Elementary, 13 points below state, versus 26% at Junior High, 6 points above. In 2024–2025, free/reduced lunch eligible shares were 34% at Elementary, 28% at Junior High, and 27% at High School; student-teacher ratios ranged from 10.3 to 13.7.
Thank you for your feedback!