Summary:
The Marion 10 school district, which ranks in the bottom 2% of South Carolina districts, operates two middle schools—Johnakin Middle and Palmetto Middle—serving grades 6-8 with a combined enrollment of about 692 students.
For parents comparing the two schools, Palmetto Middle is the stronger performer overall, despite having a larger student-teacher ratio (19.8:1 vs. 15.8:1) and spending only $745 more per student. The most dramatic gap is in 8th grade math, where Palmetto posts 20.6% proficiency versus just 3.6% at Johnakin Middle. Palmetto also shows an upward trajectory as students advance—8th grade ELA climbs to 40.2%—while Johnakin declines from 35.8% in 6th grade to 24.8% in 8th grade. Johnakin faces severe challenges, including 0% proficiency in 7th grade math and a 15.6-point drop in 8th grade ELA year-over-year. However, Johnakin does lead in 6th grade science (26.2% vs. 19.7%) and 6th grade ELA (35.8% vs. 29.0%).
Both schools struggle with chronic absenteeism, though Johnakin's rate (31.7%) exceeds Palmetto's (25.8%) and the state average (22.3%). Mathematics is a district-wide crisis, with all scores falling 20-40 points below state averages. The year-to-year volatility at both schools—such as Palmetto's 13-point jump in 8th grade math—suggests small cohorts and inconsistent instruction. While the Marion 10 district faces systemic hurdles, Palmetto's relative success in the same context shows improvement is possible, making it the more promising choice for parents seeking stronger academic outcomes, particularly in upper grades.
Thank you for your feedback!