Summary:
Buffalo, South Carolina is home to a single elementary school, Buffalo Elementary, which serves grades PK-5 with an enrollment of 483 students within the Union 01 school district.
For parents considering this school, the most striking feature is its exceptional attendance record—Buffalo Elementary reports a 0% chronic absenteeism rate, compared to roughly 23% both district-wide and statewide. The school also benefits from strong resources, including per-student spending of $14,327 and a favorable 13.4:1 student-teacher ratio. However, these advantages have not translated into academic success. Proficiency rates in 2025-2026 lag state averages by 20 to 38 percentage points across all subjects and grades. For example, only 43.3% of 3rd graders and 42.9% of 4th graders met ELA standards, while 5th-grade performance is particularly concerning at just 25.4% in ELA and 17.9% in math. The school's state ranking has also slipped to the 6th percentile, down from the 10th percentile two years ago.
The data reveals a troubling pattern of declining performance as students advance. While 3rd and 4th graders showed year-over-year improvement in ELA and math, 5th graders experienced a dramatic collapse—an 18.5-point drop in ELA and a 5.3-point drop in math. This "5th-grade cliff" suggests the current cohort may have faced learning disruptions or that the school struggles to support upper-elementary students. On a positive note, 4th-grade science jumped an impressive 11.5 points, and the school outperforms its district in that subject. Despite significant resources and perfect attendance, Buffalo Elementary consistently trails both its district and state, indicating that money and attendance alone aren't solving the academic challenges. Parents should expect that their children will need substantial academic support, particularly as they approach 5th grade, and should inquire about intervention programs and curriculum alignment when speaking with school leadership.
Thank you for your feedback!