Summary:
Achievement First Rhode Island has two middle schools serving grades 5–8: AF Iluminar Mayoral Middle School and AF Providence Mayoral Middle, each enrolling about 405 students. The most important overall difference is that Providence leads Iluminar in all three all-grade subject results for 2025–26.
AF Providence Mayoral Middle stands out overall, with 40.7% proficient in ELA, 33.7% in math and 28.8% in science—8.7, 8.3 and 4.9 percentage points above AF Iluminar Mayoral Middle School, respectively. Providence is above the state in ELA and math, but below it in science. Across both schools, the average is above the state in ELA (36.35% versus 33.1%) and below in math and science, with the largest shortfall in science (26.35% versus 31.1%). There are grade-level exceptions: Iluminar leads 7th-grade ELA, 41.6% to 40.6%, and 5th-grade science, 25.5% to 24.8%; Providence’s 8th-grade ELA is a standout at 54.1%, 21 points above the state.
Results improved overall from 2024–25, though changes differed by school and subject. Both schools raised all-grade math proficiency: Iluminar by 7.8 points and Providence by 5.8; Providence also gained 10.3 points in ELA and 8.1 in science, while Iluminar’s ELA slipped 0.8 and science fell 3.5 points. SchoolDigger ranks Providence 23rd of 68 statewide (66th percentile) and Iluminar 32nd (53rd); both have the same SchoolDigger district rank and two-star rating. Enrollment is nearly identical, while Providence has a lower student-teacher ratio (13.9 versus 20.3) and a higher free/reduced-lunch rate (85.93% versus 80.79%); these are descriptive differences and do not explain the score gap.
Thank you for your feedback!