Summary:
Zip code 74571 has five schools—two elementary schools, one junior high and two high schools—serving students from elementary through high school, with enrollments ranging from 69 to 220. The supplied 2025–2026 results show widespread proficiency challenges: none of the five schools reached the state result in either English language arts (ELA) or math, and the school averages were 13% in ELA versus 26% statewide and 9% in math versus 25%. The most important area-wide finding is that every school’s supplied ELA and math result fell below the state level.
Talihina High School stands out among the high schools, leading in ELA at 23% versus 16% at Buffalo Valley High School, and in U.S. History at 46% versus 10%. Talihina High was also 5 points above the state in U.S. History, while Buffalo Valley High was 31 points below it. Talihina Junior High School had the strongest supplied science result, 34%—4 points above the state—and led the All Grades math results at 17%, though that was below the state’s 25%. Between the elementary schools, Talihina Elementary School led ELA, 12% to 0%, while math was closer: 15% to 13%.
Scores moved in different directions over time: the five-school ELA average fell 6 points from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, math fell 2 points, and science fell 8; U.S. History rose 3 points on average. Talihina High’s U.S. History score rose 17 points even as its ELA, math and science scores fell by 10, 12 and 5 points. SchoolDigger’s 2025–2026 statewide percentiles were 32nd for Talihina Junior High, 22nd for Talihina High, 16th for Talihina Elementary and 3rd for Buffalo Valley High; Buffalo Valley High fell from the 54th percentile in 2023–2024. For context, in 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible enrollment ranged from 56% at Talihina Elementary to 81% at Buffalo Valley Elementary, while student-teacher ratios ranged from 9.5 at Talihina Junior High to 21.1 at Buffalo Valley Elementary. Schools serve different grade spans, and the small enrollments mean these figures are best considered alongside each school’s specific results.
Thank you for your feedback!