Summary:
Carney Elementary School serves PK–8 and Carney High School serves grades 9–12; together they enroll 212 students, 142 in elementary and 70 in high school. The clearest academic distinction is at the high school: in 2025–2026, 47% were proficient in U.S. History, above the state’s 41%, while 9% were proficient in mathematics, well below the state’s 25%. This sharp subject-by-subject contrast is the most important finding for families comparing the schools.
Carney High School stands out for graduation and U.S. History: its 2024–2025 graduation rate was 90%, compared with 78% statewide, a 13-point advantage, and its latest U.S. History result was 6 points above the state. Carney Elementary School led the supplied 2024–2025 science results, with 33% proficient versus 30% statewide; the high school’s science result that year was 12%, 18 points below the state. In the latest results, high-school ELA was also below the state rate, 15% versus 26%. Both schools had lower chronic absenteeism than the state in 2025–2026: 4% at the elementary school and 7% at the high school, versus 16% statewide.
Results changed in different directions by school and subject. Elementary mathematics rose from 17% proficient in 2024–2025 to 25% in 2025–2026, matching the latest state rate; high-school mathematics fell from 11% to 9%, while ELA fell from 21% to 15% at both schools. Across ELA and mathematics at both schools, the simple average moved from 18% to 16%, while the state average rounded to 26% in both years, widening the gap from 9 to 10 points. SchoolDigger’s high-school percentile ranking improved from 18 in 2023–2024 to 35 in 2025–2026, though that relative ranking does not mean proficiency rose in every subject. In 2024–2025, student-teacher ratios were 13.9 at the elementary school and 10.2 at the high school; the free/reduced lunch eligible shares that year were 73% and 80%, respectively. These are contextual figures, not explanations for achievement; the schools serve different grade spans and both have small enrollments.
Thank you for your feedback!