Summary:
ZIP code 44827 covers five schools — three elementary and two high schools, with no middle or alternative schools — serving about 1,223 students across two districts that perform very differently: Colonel Crawford Local with 719 students and Crestline Exempted Village with 504. Colonel Crawford Local is rated 4 stars and the 72nd percentile (214th of 773 districts), while Crestline Exempted Village is rated 1 star and the 23rd percentile (598th of 773).
Col Crawford High School is the strongest school in the ZIP: a 100% graduation rate, 6.6% chronic absenteeism, and 2025-26 end-of-course scores above the state in every reported subject, including American History at 94.8% vs 73.2% and Biology at 85.1% vs 67.0%. Hannah Crawford Elementary School grades 3 -5 is the strongest tested elementary, rated 3 stars and 63rd percentile, with 5.6% absenteeism and most tests above state — though 5th-grade math is a clear weakness at 29.8% vs the state's 59.1%. Hannah Crawford Elementary School PreK-Grade 2 has no test or rank data because it serves PreK-2; it has low absenteeism (5.5%) and the ZIP's highest student-teacher ratio (21.8).
Crestline High School is the area's biggest concern: 1 star, 19th percentile, an 87.5% graduation rate, the ZIP's highest chronic absenteeism at 26.5%, and severe math weaknesses in Geometry (17.6%) and Algebra I (31.0%), both far below state. Crestline Elementary School is improving — from 1 star to 2 stars and from the 26th to the 42nd percentile — with absenteeism of 12.4% and 4th-grade ELA at 77.8% vs 61.8%, but 3rd-grade math and ELA both sit at 50%. Note that free/reduced lunch figures are missing for the Crestline schools (unknown, not zero), and spending figures date to 2018-19.
Thank you for your feedback!