Summary:
ZIP code 44824 in Castalia, Ohio, contains three schools serving about 1,566 students: one elementary school (grades PK–5) and two high schools (grades 6–12 and 9–12), with no middle or alternative schools. The schools span two districts — Margaretta Local, which includes Margaretta Elementary School and Margaretta High School, and Townsend Community School, which operates as its own district. Test-score data is available for both 2024–25 and 2025–26 at the Margaretta schools, but only for 2024–25 at Townsend, and Townsend's free/reduced-lunch and per-student spending figures are not reported.
The two Margaretta schools generally outperform Ohio state averages. At Margaretta High School, students beat the state average in 12 of 13 reported test areas in 2025–26, including Science 8th grade at 83.5% vs. 61.2% statewide and Biology at 82.9% vs. 67.0%. Its graduation rate is 98.8% and its student-teacher ratio is 17.2, though Geometry proficiency (40.5%) fell below the state's 43.3% for a second straight year. Margaretta Elementary School shines in 4th-grade math — 90.3% proficient in 2025–26 and 96.9% in 2024–25, far above state averages — with chronic absenteeism of 14.9%, well below the district's 19.9%.
Townsend Community School faces severe challenges by comparison. Its graduation rate is 40.4% — 58.4 points below Margaretta High — and its chronic absenteeism is 45.4%, notably higher than the district rate of 19.9%. Its 2024–25 test scores trail the state by wide margins in every reported subject, including Algebra I at 3.0% vs. 59.4% and Geometry at 1.2% vs. 42.8%. Its student-teacher ratio of 30.3 is roughly 1.8 times those of the Margaretta schools. Notably, the two high schools are listed at nearly the same address (207 and 209 Lowell St), yet the gap in outcomes between them is striking.
Thank you for your feedback!