Summary:
ZIP code 44654 in Millersburg, Ohio contains five schools — one elementary, one middle, and three high schools — serving about 1,263 students, with four of the five in West Holmes Local and one in Buckeye. West Holmes Local is ranked 291 of 773 schools, at the 62nd percentile with 3 stars, but that district-wide number hides wide differences among its individual schools.
Millersburg Elementary School is the strongest academic standout: 319 of 1,560 (80th percentile, 4 stars) in 2025–2026, up from the 71st percentile in 2023–2024, with every reported 2025–2026 test above the state average, including 4th-grade math at 94.4% and 5th-grade ELA at 92.1%. It also posts the highest reported free/reduced lunch rate among reported schools, 46.26%. West Holmes Middle School is close behind at 264 of 1,046 (75th percentile, 4 stars), led by math — 7th-grade math 67.2% vs. state 48.6%, 8th-grade math 70.2% vs. state 52%, and Algebra I End-of-Course at 100%, though that last figure likely reflects a small or selective group. West Holmes High School ranks lowest of the three at the 46th percentile with 2 stars, down from the 63rd percentile in 2023–2024, even though its 98.6% graduation rate tops the district's 95.5%.
Attendance is the sharpest contrast: chronic absenteeism is 6.6% at Millersburg Elementary, 6.3% at West Holmes Digital Academy, 16.9% at the middle school, and 25.2% at the high school, far above the district rate of 14.3%. High school Algebra I is a weak spot at 56%, below both district (60.5%) and state (61.6%), even though middle school math is a strength. Two schools — West Holmes Digital Academy (34 students, 73.7% graduation) and Buckeye Career Center Annex-Hiland Satellite (6 students) — are too small to compare fairly.
Thank you for your feedback!