Summary:
ZIP code 44442 in New Middletown, Ohio is served by exactly three schools — all part of the Springfield Local district — forming a complete, self-contained K–12 pipeline of 858 students on Youngstown Pittsburgh Road: Springfield Elementary School (K–4, 347 students), Springfield Intermediate Middle School (5–8, 268 students), and Springfield High School (9–12, 243 students). Every child in this ZIP moves through these same three buildings.
The three schools are heading in very different directions. Springfield High School is the standout: 5 stars, 69th of 795 high schools (91st percentile), a 100.0% graduation rate, and an average of about +22 points over the state in every End-of-Course subject. It has climbed from the 71st to the 91st percentile in three years. Springfield Intermediate Middle School is the steady anchor — 4 stars all three years at the 86th–88th percentile, with a remarkable 94.8% proficiency on 7th-grade ELA (+32.1 over state). Springfield Elementary School is the concern: its rating fell from 4 stars to 3, and it dropped 15 percentile points (83 to 68), driven by 3rd-grade ELA sliding from 81.9% to 67.2%.
Parents should note some practical differences. The elementary has the largest classes (19.2 students per teacher) and the lowest recorded per-student spending ($8,009, 2018–19 data), while the high school has the smallest classes (11.5) and highest spending ($11,955). Absenteeism is low everywhere — 9.6%, 10.0%, and 11.3% — and does not explain the elementary slide. Enrollment tapers gently (about 69, 67, and 61 students per grade), suggesting stable-to-slightly-smaller cohorts ahead. The clearest thing to watch is whether the elementary's literacy decline continues, since those students will eventually arrive at an otherwise thriving secondary system.
Thank you for your feedback!