Summary:
ZIP code 44287 in West Salem, Ohio, is served by three public schools: Northwestern Elementary School (PK–5, 632 students), Northwestern Middle School (6–8, 284 students), and Northwestern High School (9–12, 327 students). All three belong to the Northwestern Local district, which enrolls 1,243 students and ranks 159th of 773 Ohio districts — the 79th percentile, with 4 stars. Every school earned 4 stars in 2025–2026, and each posted proficiency above the state average on every reported test that year.
The schools differ in where their strengths show. Northwestern Elementary School is the largest school and the most consistent academic performer, with especially strong math: 3rd-grade math at 79.7% versus 62.1% statewide, 4th-grade math at 92.3% versus 67.3%, and 5th-grade math at 86.7% versus 59.1%. Its rank has held steady near the 80th percentile for three years. Northwestern Middle School holds the highest current standing at the 81st percentile, up from the 67th the prior year, with 8th-grade science at 88.2% versus 61.2% statewide and 7th-grade ELA at 81.2% versus 62.7%. Northwestern High School shows the biggest turnaround, rising from the 42nd percentile with 2 stars to the 71st percentile with 4 stars; Algebra I climbed from 39.7% to 69.5% and Geometry from 28.0% to 51.9%. Its graduation rate is 99.0%.
The clearest concern is attendance at the high school: chronic absenteeism there is 22.8%, well above the district's 14.9% and far higher than the elementary school's 12.0% and the middle school's 13.2%. Free/reduced lunch participation also rises with grade level — 43.67% at the elementary, 45.77% at the middle, and 51.99% at the high school. Student-teacher ratios run 16.8, 15.0, and 13.7 respectively, while per-student spending (2018–2019 data) is highest at the high school at $12,466 and lowest at the middle school at $7,854. Families may find it useful to ask about current attendance supports at the high school.
Thank you for your feedback!