Schools in Zip Code 43333

ZIP code 43333 in Lewistown, Ohio, is served by three public schools in Indian Lake Local—Indian Lake Elementary School (PK–4, 530 students), Indian Lake Middle School (5–8, 393 students), and Indian Lake High School (9–12, 441 students)—with 1,364 students total. The district is ranked 166th of 773 Ohio districts, in the 79th percentile with 4 stars.

For parents comparing academics, Indian Lake Middle School is the strongest overall performer: 155th of 1,046 schools, 85th percentile, 4 stars, with all reported 2025–26 tests above state averages. Highlights include Algebra I End of Course 100% proficient vs. state 61.6%, 5th grade math 81.3% vs. 59.1%, and 7th grade ELA 83.2% vs. 62.7%. Indian Lake Elementary School also stands out and is improving: its 2025–26 rank is 289th of 1,560 (81st percentile, 4 stars), up from 73rd percentile in 2023–24. Its 3rd grade ELA is 94.8% proficient vs. state 63.4%, the highest in this data set, and 4th grade math is 84.5% vs. 67.3%. Indian Lake High School is improving but uneven: rank rose to 296th of 795 (63rd percentile, 3 stars), graduation rate is 98.3%, and Algebra I improved to 81.6% vs. state 61.6%; Geometry remains below state at 36.2% vs. 43.3%.

Attendance and school environment differ. Indian Lake Elementary School has the lowest chronic absenteeism at 9.0%, while Indian Lake Middle School is 11.9% and Indian Lake High School is highest at 16.5%, above the district’s 12.2%. The middle school has the lowest student-teacher ratio (15.7) and highest 2018–19 per-student spending ($10,844); the high school has the highest ratio (20.0) and the elementary school the lowest spending ($9,280) but still strong results. Overall, Indian Lake Local is a high-performing district with especially strong elementary and middle schools; the high school is trending upward, with Geometry and absenteeism as the main areas to watch.