Summary
Dover High School is the only high school in the Dover City district in Tuscarawas County, Ohio, serving 823 students in grades 9–12. In 2025–2026 it ranked 346th of 795 Ohio high schools (56th percentile, 3 stars), while the district ranked 229th of 773 (70th percentile, 4 stars) — a sign the high school is the weaker link in a stronger district. It is the largest traditional 9–12 high school in its local comparison group, ahead of New Philadelphia High School (748 students), Garaway High School (441), and Indian Valley High School (422).
Dover's strengths are in reading-, writing-, and content-heavy subjects. It beats the state average in four of six End-of-Course exams — American History 84.0% vs. 73.2%, English II 75.3% vs. 62.7%, Biology 79.3% vs. 67.0%, and American Government 80.7% vs. 71.6% — and does so by the widest margins in its area. It also performs notably well by two groups that often trail elsewhere: students from low-income families rank in the 80th percentile statewide, and gifted students in the 87th. It manages this with the largest classes of any nearby high school (20 students per teacher) and among the leanest budgets in the group — $9,022 per pupil, compared with $10,426 at Tuscarawas Valley and $10,716 at Indian Valley.
Two persistent problems hold the school back. Math is the clearest weak spot: Geometry proficiency is 41.2% (state: 43.3%) and Algebra I 52.8% (state: 61.6%), and the school's Algebra I result trails its own district's by 7.6 to 12.2 points every year. Even against New Philadelphia High School, its nearest neighbor at 2.61 miles, Dover wins on overall rank, graduation (86.0% vs. 77.1%), absenteeism, and every non-math test — but loses both math exams. Attendance is the second issue: 19.7% of students are chronically absent, roughly 1 in 5, more than double Garaway (9.3%) and Tuscarawas Valley Middle-High School (9.6%), and graduation ranks 9th of 10 locally. Dover is a solid mid-tier school whose ceiling is limited mainly by math and attendance.
Thank you for your feedback!