Summary:
Bexley City operates five schools — three elementary schools serving PK–5, one middle school serving grades 6–8, and one high school serving grades 9–12 — enrolling a combined 2,494 students. The district ranks 34th of 773 in Ohio, placing it in the 96th percentile, and all five schools currently hold 5 stars in the 2025–2026 rankings. Enrollment is split with about 45.6% in the elementary schools, 23.7% in the middle school, and 30.7% in the high school.
Every school performs well above state averages in every listed test subject. Bexley High School is the district's top-ranked school (27th of 795, 97th percentile) with a 99.5% graduation rate, and its strongest results include American Government at 96.6% and American History at 96.5%, though Geometry (79.1%) is its lowest listed subject. Among elementaries, Maryland Elementary School ranks highest (79th of 1,560) and leads all Bexley elementaries in math at every listed grade — 3rd grade 92.7%, 4th grade 92.2%, and 5th grade 88.5%. Montrose Elementary School (88th of 1,560) posts the district's best 5th grade science and ELA scores, both 94.6%, and has the lowest student-teacher ratio at 14.6. Bexley Middle School (82nd of 1,046) reports 100% Algebra I proficiency in both of the last two years — higher than the high school's rate. Cassingham Elementary School (127th of 1,560) is the lowest-ranked Bexley school but still in the 92nd percentile.
One clear internal contrast is attendance: elementary chronic absenteeism ranges from 4.0% at Cassingham to 5.2% at Maryland, all below the district's 7.9%, while the middle school (10.8%) and high school (10.5%) are both above it. Maryland, Montrose, and Cassingham also improved their percentile ranks since 2023–2024, with Maryland jumping from the 83rd to the 95th percentile. Overall, families will find consistent top-decile performance at every level, with the main differences showing up in which subjects and grade levels are strongest.
Thank you for your feedback!