Summary:
ZIP code 14609 has 10 schools, from prekindergarten through grade 12, including elementary, middle, and high schools; results and programs vary across the area. In 2025–26, the clearest area-wide concern is math: elementary schools averaged 32 points below state results in math, compared with 25 points below in ELA, and middle schools averaged 37 points below in math versus 27 points below in ELA.
Several schools lead in particular grades and subjects, rather than one school standing out across the board. Laurelton-Pardee Intermediate School led grade 5 science at 39%, compared with 7% at School 52-Frank Fowler Dow—a 31-point spread—and also led grade 4 and 5 math. East Irondequoit Middle School led grade 7 and 8 ELA and grade 6 and 7 math; its grade 7 math result was 44%, 21 points above the next-highest school. There are notable exceptions: East Lower School led grade 6 ELA at 44%, while Andrew A Langston Middle School led grade 8 science at 20%. At the high-school level, strengths also depend on the subject: East Upper High School had 100% proficiency in Algebra II Regents, while Vertus Charter School led in several other shared Regents subjects.
Recent changes are mixed, so families may want to compare specific grades and subjects rather than assume results are rising uniformly. Northwest College Preparatory High School improved across its listed grade 7–8 ELA and math results from 2024–25 to 2025–26, while School 52 had declines in grade 5 ELA and science but a rise in grade 4 math. SchoolDigger’s percentile rank for East Irondequoit Middle fell from 27 to 14 over three years; these are SchoolDigger rankings, not test-score percentages. All 10 schools reported free/reduced lunch eligible figures for 2024–25, ranging from 61% at Helendale Road Primary School to 94% at East Lower. High-school outcomes also warrant attention: 2024–25 graduation rates were 71% at East Upper and 76% at Vertus, below the state’s 83%, while chronic absenteeism was 64% and 86%, respectively, compared with 31% statewide. Because school grade spans and available tests differ, these figures do not establish one overall ranking of all 10 schools.
Thank you for your feedback!