Summary:
Zip code 14445 includes two schools in the East Rochester Union Free School District: East Rochester Elementary School serves prekindergarten through grade 5 and has 432 students, while East Rochester Junior-Senior High School serves grades 6–12 and has 490. Their 2025–2026 assessment results show a notable contrast: elementary math is strong in grades 3 and 4, while the junior-senior high school is below state results in all seven reported grade 6–8 subjects. The most important takeaway is that results vary considerably by grade and subject, rather than showing one consistently stronger school.
The elementary school’s clearest strengths are grade 4 math, at 72% proficient versus 61% statewide, and grade 3 math, at 69% versus 59%. Its biggest weakness is grade 5 math: 38% versus 54% statewide, a 17-point shortfall; grade 5 ELA and science are also below state results. The junior-senior high school’s grade 6–8 average is 45% versus 51% statewide, with its largest subject-level concern in ELA, averaging 41% versus 51%. Its Regents results are more mixed: Regents English Language Arts is 96% versus 77% statewide, while Common Core English Language Arts is 20% versus 74%. The schools serve different tested grades, so their assessment results are not a like-for-like comparison.
Results moved closer to state averages over time, although not in the same way at both schools: the elementary school’s matched assessment average fell from 51% to 50%, while its state gap narrowed from 3 points below to 1 point below; the junior-senior high school’s average rose from 38% to 45%, narrowing its gap from 12 points below to 7. SchoolDigger gives both schools three stars; the elementary school ranks 1,189 of 2,444 schools (51st percentile), and the junior-senior high school ranks 531 of 1,258 (58th percentile). For 2024–2025, 38% of elementary students and 37% of junior-senior high students were free/reduced lunch eligible. Their student-teacher ratios are 10.4 and 9.3, respectively—useful context, but not an explanation for the differing results.
Thank you for your feedback!