Summary:
ZIP code 14215 has seven schools in the Buffalo City School District, serving students from prekindergarten through grade 12 across different grade spans. The supplied 2025–2026 state assessment results cover five schools; PS 84 has no scores in the data. Across the reported school-grade results, unweighted averages were 29% in ELA, 31% in math and 24% in science, compared with matched state averages of 48%, 56% and 47%. The gaps were 19, 25 and 23 percentage points, respectively. The clearest area-wide takeaway is that results generally trail the state, while performance can differ sharply between schools serving the same grade.
Frederick Olmsted #156 is the strongest tested school most consistently in grades 5–8: it led same-grade schools in ELA and math across those grades, and in grade 5 science. In grade 8 ELA, it scored 85%, compared with 18% at the next-highest school, Highgate Heights—a 67-point gap—and 53% statewide. Olmsted’s grade 7 math score was 73%, 62 points above Highgate Heights and 14 points above the state. PS 61 Arthur O. Eve stands out in grade 4 ELA at 60%, compared with 36% at the next-highest school. Highgate Heights and Pantoja often had the lowest results, though which school ranked lowest varied by grade and subject.
Recent results show no uniform trend: across 46 matched grade-and-subject comparisons, school results rose an average of 1 percentage point from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, while state results fell 2 points. Math improved by 4 points on average, but science fell 3. SchoolDigger’s statewide percentiles also shifted: Olmsted rose from the 44th to 51st percentile, while Highgate Heights moved from the 1st to 5th. As context, all seven schools reported the same low-income measure—free/reduced lunch eligible—in 2024–2025, ranging from 61% at Olmsted to 97% at Ronald Peoples School of Scholars; that difference does not explain outcomes. Olmsted also combined a 94% graduation rate with 47% chronic absenteeism in 2024–2025, compared with 83% and 31% statewide.
Thank you for your feedback!