Summary:
ZIP code 14212 has two schools: Harriet Ross Tubman Academy, serving prekindergarten through grade 8, and Woodrow Wilson Elementary School, serving grades 3–5. The fairest comparison is in grades 3–5, which both schools serve. In 2025–26, Wilson’s average proficiency was 36% in ELA and 55% in math, compared with Tubman’s 8% and 14%; the single most important finding is that Wilson led Tubman by 28 percentage points in ELA and 42 points in math across these shared grades.
Wilson stands out as the stronger performer in every subject the schools share, while Tubman’s results were much lower in grades 3–5. Wilson also led in grade 5 science, with 39% proficient versus 10% at Tubman, a 29-point difference. Wilson’s math results were close to the state average overall: its grades 3–5 average was 55%, compared with 58% statewide, and its grade 4 and 5 rates exceeded the state rates. Tubman’s grade 8 results offer a notable exception to its lower shared-grade results: 32% were proficient in ELA and 26% in science, above the corresponding figures for the Buffalo City School District, but below state results.
Recent results show different patterns: Wilson’s grades 3–5 ELA average fell 16 points from 2024–25 to 2025–26, while its math average slipped by about 1 point. Tubman’s grades 3–5 ELA average fell by 2 points and its math average rose by 5; its grade 8 ELA and science results also rose by 12 and 26 points. SchoolDigger ranked Wilson 1,466th of 2,444 schools (40th percentile, 2 stars) and Tubman 2,429th (1st percentile, 0 stars) in 2025–26. In 2024–25, free/reduced lunch eligible students made up 60% at Wilson and 98% at Tubman; the figures describe school context, not the reason for score differences. Tubman enrolled 550 students and had an 11.3 student–teacher ratio, compared with 284 students and a 12.7 ratio at Wilson.
Thank you for your feedback!