Summary:
ZIP code 14138 has two schools in the Pine Valley Central School District (South Dayton): Pine Valley Elementary School, serving pre-K through grade 6 with 319 students, and Pine Valley Central Junior-Senior High School, serving grades 7–12 with 199 students. Their different grade spans mean their test scores are not direct comparisons. The main finding is that both schools’ 2025–2026 assessment averages were below same-grade state averages, with the largest average gap in the high school’s grades 7–8 math: 24 points.
Within the elementary school, grade 4 was a relative bright spot: ELA was 37% and math 51%, the school’s highest results in those subjects, though still below state results of 48% and 61%. Its lowest results were grade 3 ELA at 16% versus 42% statewide and grade 6 math at 20% versus 52%. The high school averaged 38% in grades 7–8 ELA versus 52% statewide, and 28% in math versus 52%. Its results also include notable strengths and weaknesses: graduation was 94% in 2024–2025 versus 83% statewide, and 2025–2026 Algebra II Regents results were 100% versus 80% statewide; Chemistry was 20% versus 73% statewide.
Recent changes were mixed, rather than a consistent rise or fall. The elementary school’s math gap narrowed from 21 points to 19 between 2024–2025 and 2025–2026, while its ELA gap stayed about 20 points; grade 4 improved 16 points in ELA and 22 points in math. At the high school, the grades 7–8 ELA gap narrowed from 15 points to 14, but the math gap widened from 17 to 24 points. SchoolDigger rates the elementary school one star and places it in the 14th percentile, while the high school receives two stars and ranks in the 47th percentile for 2025–2026. In 2024–2025, free/reduced lunch eligible students were 52% at the elementary school and 40% at the high school; student-teacher ratios were 11 and 6.6, respectively. These figures offer context, not an explanation for achievement.
Thank you for your feedback!