Summary:
ZIP code 14127 includes six Orchard Park Central School District schools: four elementary schools, one middle school and one high school, serving students from elementary through high school. In 2025–2026, elementary results averaged 56% in ELA, 73% in math and 57% in fifth-grade science, each about 12 to 15 points above state averages. Still, school results varied substantially, with gaps of 29 points in fifth-grade ELA and 34 points in fifth-grade science. The most important takeaway is that area averages are strong, but they do not describe every school or subject equally well.
Ellicott Road Elementary had the strongest broad elementary profile: it led four of seven grade-and-subject comparisons and averaged 60% in ELA, 79% in math and 71% in fifth-grade science. Eggert Road Elementary had the standout fifth-grade ELA result at 75%, 14 points above the next-highest school. Windom Elementary had the weakest fifth-grade results: 45% in ELA, 52% in math and 38% in science; math and science were 2 and 8 points below state results. Orchard Park Middle School was above the state on every reported assessment, including by 20 points in sixth-grade math. Orchard Park High School had strong results in some Regents exams, including 100% in Algebra II, but Living Environment was 28%, 16 points below the state.
Recent changes were mixed: elementary math and fifth-grade science averages rose by 4 points each from 2024–2025, while ELA fell by 9 points. At the high school, Living Environment dropped from 90% to 28%, despite strong results on other exams. SchoolDigger’s 2025–2026 rankings placed Ellicott at the 85th percentile and Windom at the 63rd; their rankings were 6 and 9 percentile points lower than in 2023–2024. As context, the elementary schools’ free/reduced lunch eligible shares in school year 2024–2025 ranged from 11% to 18%, and their student-teacher ratios ranged from 11.2 to 12.6; these figures do not show a consistent pattern alongside results.
Thank you for your feedback!