Summary:
ZIP code 14108 has three schools in the Newfane Central School District, serving students from kindergarten through grade 12: Newfane Elementary School (K–4), Newfane Middle School (4–8) and Newfane Senior High School (7–12). The clearest concern in the available 2025–2026 results is middle-school grade 5: math was 20% compared with 54% statewide, and ELA was 23% compared with 43% statewide.
Results vary substantially by grade and subject, so no single school is strongest across the board. Newfane Elementary stands out in math: grade 3 was 64%, 5 points above the state, and grade 4 was 63%, 2 points above. Newfane Middle had a bright spot in grade 6 ELA, at 56% versus 50% statewide, but grade 5 math was 34 points below the state. Newfane Senior High was above state results on several reported Regents exams: Earth and Space Sciences was 72% versus 50%, and Algebra II was 100% versus 80%; Geometry was 6 points below the state.
Some results improved while others did not. From 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, the average gap from state results narrowed in ELA, from 12 points below to 6 below, and in math, from 12 below to 10 below; middle-school science moved the other way, from 6 points below to 16 below. Elementary grade 4 math rose 19 points year over year. SchoolDigger’s latest ranking percentiles also rose for all three schools: 12 points for Elementary, 12 for Middle and 11 for Senior High, though Senior High remains 5 points below its percentile three years earlier. Student–teacher ratios range from 10.1 to 11.3. The schools’ 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible shares range from 35% at Middle to 41% at Elementary; these are contextual measures, not explanations for results. Some overlapping-grade test results are suppressed, so a complete school-to-school ranking is not available.
Thank you for your feedback!