Summary:
Zip code 14006 has five schools: two elementary schools, one middle school, one high school and one alternative school, serving families from elementary through high school. The alternative school, Erie 2-Chautauqua-Cattaraugus BOCES, has no reported test results. Across the two elementary schools and William G Houston Middle School, every reported 2025–2026 grade-level score was below the matching state result. The most important area-wide finding is that elementary and middle-school assessment results are consistently below state benchmarks.
A J Schmidt Elementary School leads the elementary comparison, winning four of seven matched results; its average was 36%, versus 32% at John T Waugh Elementary School, a 4-point difference. Schmidt’s largest leads were in grade 4 ELA (47% versus 23%) and math (57% versus 35%), while Waugh led in grade 5 ELA and math. Schmidt’s notable weak spot was grade 5 ELA at 10%, compared with Waugh’s 22% and the state’s 43%. Houston’s average was 32%, about 20 points below the state average of 51%. At the high school, Lake Shore Senior High School had strong Regents results in Algebra II (98%) and Common Core ELA (90%), but low results in Living Environment (22%) and Earth Science (30%).
Elementary averages fell from 36% in 2024–2025 to 34% in 2025–2026, but the gap with the state narrowed from 19 to 17 points. Houston’s average also fell, from 34% to 32%, while its gap widened from 16 to 20 points. Lake Shore’s SchoolDigger statewide ranking moved from the 57th percentile to the 65th, then the 58th, over the last three reported years. As context, in 2024–2025 Schmidt had 42% free/reduced lunch eligible and a 10.2 student-teacher ratio; Waugh had 50% free/reduced lunch eligible and an 8.4 ratio. These are observations, not explanations for test results.
Thank you for your feedback!