Summary:
ZIP code 13032 has four schools in the Canastota Central School District, serving prekindergarten through grade 12: Peterboro Street Elementary (PK–2), South Side Elementary (grades 3–4), Roberts Street Middle (grades 5–8), and Canastota High (grades 9–12). Enrollment ranges from 182 students at South Side to 373 at the high school. The clearest area-wide pattern is that ELA results trail state levels much more than math: across grades 3–8, the average ELA gap was 15 points below state, compared with math just 1 point below.
Roberts Street stands out for middle-grade math: grade 5 and 6 proficiency exceeded state rates by 8 and 13 points, respectively, and its average math result across grades 5–8 was 2 points above state. Its average ELA result, however, was 12 points below state. South Side is the weakest relative to state in the reported elementary grades, especially in ELA: its average gap was 22 points below state, compared with a 5-point gap below state in math. The high school had a mixed but mostly strong Regents profile: 10 of 12 numeric results were above state, though the separately listed English Language Arts result was 20 points below and Algebra I was 7 points below.
Recent results and SchoolDigger rankings show different trajectories across schools. From 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, South Side’s average ELA score fell 18 points and its math score fell 8; Roberts Street’s average science score fell 8, while its ELA and math averages each declined about 4 points. The high school’s SchoolDigger percentile remained fairly steady at 61, 59, and 62 across the three listed years; Roberts Street fell from 48 to 36 and South Side from 42 to 24 between 2024–2025 and 2025–2026. In 2024–2025, free/reduced lunch eligible shares ranged from 31% at Peterboro Street to 44% at South Side, while student-teacher ratios ranged from 9.0 to 13.6; these are contextual figures, not explanations for results. Test scores are unavailable for Peterboro Street, and the state suppressed Canastota High’s 2025–2026 Chemistry and Common Core Algebra II figures.
Thank you for your feedback!