Summary:
Schools in ZIP code 11803 include eight schools serving 5,773 students, from elementary grades through high school, across the Plainview-Old Bethpage Central School District, Syosset Central School District and Bethpage Union Free School District. The latest elementary and middle-school results show average ELA performance 25 points above the state and math 28 points above it. Results are not uniformly strong, however: some science scores fall below state levels. The most important takeaway is a strong overall picture with meaningful differences by grade and subject.
Baylis Elementary School led the four schools with fifth-grade results, scoring 77% in ELA, 91% in math and 83% in science—34, 36 and 37 points above state rates. H B Mattlin Middle School led 7 of 8 middle-school ELA and math comparisons and both reported science grades; its eighth-grade science score was 71%, compared with 36% at Plainview-Old Bethpage Middle School and 49% statewide. At the elementary level, Kramer Lane Elementary School led third-grade math at 90%, and Judy Jacobs Parkway Elementary School led fourth-grade math at 97%. Pasadena had the lowest third-grade ELA score, 53%, 25 points below Baylis’s 79%.
Scores shifted considerably from the prior year: the average state-relative result across 46 matched school-grade comparisons moved down 2 points, while Mattlin improved its relative ELA position in all four tested grades. Notable declines included a 26-point drop in eighth-grade math at Plainview-Old Bethpage Middle School and a 28-point drop in third-grade ELA at Pasadena Elementary School. SchoolDigger ranks Baylis in the 94th statewide percentile and Mattlin in the 95th; these ratings offer a longer view but do not replace grade-specific results. Context measures also vary: free/reduced lunch eligible (FRL) shares in 2024–2025 ranged from 10% at Judy Jacobs to 21% at Kramer Lane, with student-teacher ratios from 10.2 to 12.9.
Thank you for your feedback!