Summary:
Schools in zip code 11742 include three schools in Sachem Central School District: Chippewa Elementary School and Waverly Avenue School serve grades K–5, and Sagamore Middle School serves grades 6–8. In 2025–2026, the schools’ average math proficiency was 57%, close to the grade-matched state average of 56%; their average ELA proficiency was 32%, well below the state’s 47%. The clearest shared academic challenge in the area is ELA, not math.
Waverly Avenue stands out among the elementary schools, with average math proficiency of 64% and ELA of 37%, compared with 58% and 25% at Chippewa. Waverly’s grade 4 and 5 math results were 75% and 70%, beating state results by 14 and 16 points; its grade 5 science result was 72%, 27 points above the state. Its results are not uniformly high: grade 3 and 4 ELA were 11 and 20 points below state results. Chippewa’s clearest bright spot was grade 3 math at 56%, just 3 points below the state, while its ELA results fell short of state results by 12 to 24 points across grades 3–5. Sagamore’s average state-test results were 18 points below the state in ELA and 3 points below in math, but its Regents results were exceptional: 100% proficiency in Algebra I and 94% in Earth and Space Sciences, compared with state results of 60% and 50%.
Recent results moved in different directions: the area’s ELA gap with the state widened by 5 points from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, while its math position was nearly unchanged. SchoolDigger’s statewide ranking percentile fell from 58 to 29 for Sagamore, while it rose from 30 to 38 for Chippewa and from 43 to 56 for Waverly. The elementary schools have similar enrollment and staffing ratios: Waverly enrolled 497 students with a 11.8 student-teacher ratio, versus 543 students and 12.2 at Chippewa. Both reported free/reduced lunch eligible for 2024–2025: 25% at Waverly and 29% at Chippewa; these figures are context, not an explanation for score differences.
Thank you for your feedback!