Summary:
ZIP code 11507 has three schools serving grades PK–8: Herricks Middle School (grades 6–8), Searingtown School (K–5), and Meadow Drive School (PK–2). The two schools with 2025–26 test results are consistently well above state results: every reported grade-level ELA and math result exceeded its matching state result, with average school–state gaps ranging from 29 to 37 percentage points.
Herricks Middle stands out in middle-school results, with average gaps of 32 points in ELA and 37 in math; its grade 8 math result was 83%, compared with 46% statewide. Searingtown stands out in elementary results, with average gaps of 35 points in ELA and 29 in math; its grade 5 ELA result was 90%, a 47-point advantage over the state. These are standouts in their respective grade ranges, not a direct school-to-school ranking. Meadow Drive has no test scores in the supplied data, so it cannot be placed at the top or bottom by achievement.
Results changed unevenly over time: Herricks grade 8 science rose from 51% in 2024–25 to 72% in 2025–26, while Searingtown grade 5 science edged down from 83% to 82% and remained far above the state. SchoolDigger ranks Herricks at the 96th percentile and Searingtown at the 94th percentile for 2025–26; Meadow Drive’s supplied ranking history is from 2009–10 to 2011–12. As context, all three reported free/reduced lunch eligible figures for 2024–25: 21% at Herricks, 25% at Searingtown, and 21% at Meadow Drive. Student–teacher ratios were 11.3, 11.5, and 14.1, respectively.
Thank you for your feedback!