Summary:
Schools in ZIP code 11418 include 10 schools—nine elementary schools and one high school—with a combined enrollment of 5,748; eight elementary schools report the latest test results, while PS 51 has no scores listed. The clearest overall finding is that elementary results vary widely: the strongest schools are well above state results on many tests, while the lowest-performing schools fall below them.
PS 66 Jacqueline Kennedy-Onassis is the broadest academic standout, leading five of seven elementary comparisons and scoring above the state in all seven; its 87% in grade 5 math is 33 points above the state. PS 55 Maure is another bright spot, with 91% in grade 4 math, 31 points above the state. PS 273 leads grade 4 ELA at 75%, but its grade 5 ELA and math results—31% and 38%—are the lowest in the area for those tests. PS 54 Hillside is below the state in all seven comparisons, including grade 5 science, where its 28% result is 18 points below the state. The school-to-school spread is at least 30 points on every test and reaches 49 points in grade 5 math.
Elementary results fell over the past year: the average across the seven tests went from 63% in 2024–2025 to 53% in 2025–2026, while the matching state average fell from 55% to 50%. ELA and math school averages remain above state averages, but grade 5 science is below. SchoolDigger rankings show mixed movement: PS 55 rose from the 74th to the 82nd percentile, while PS 66 fell from the 96th to the 87th despite leading current tests. Student–teacher ratios also vary: PS 54 has a ratio of 12.1, compared with 16.3 at S.T.A.R. Leadership Academy. For school year 2024–2025, free/reduced lunch eligible rates were 80% at PS 66 and 83% at PS 55; these figures are context, not an explanation for results.
Thank you for your feedback!