Summary:
ZIP code 10989 has two elementary schools in the Nyack Union Free School District: Liberty Elementary School serves kindergarten through grade 5, and Valley Cottage School serves prekindergarten through grade 5. The clearest area-wide strength in the 2025–2026 results is math: the schools’ average was 70%, compared with 58% statewide. The most important difference for families comparing the schools is that Valley Cottage’s math results were substantially higher, especially in grades 4 and 5.
Valley Cottage stands out in math and grade 5 science, while Liberty had mixed results by grade. Valley Cottage averaged 79% in math, 19 percentage points above Liberty’s 61%; it led by 23 points in grade 4 and 26 in grade 5. In science, Valley Cottage scored 66%, versus Liberty’s 49%, a 17-point gap. ELA was less one-sided: Valley Cottage averaged 51% and Liberty 44%, but Liberty led in grade 4 by 9 points. Valley Cottage’s grade 4 ELA score of 40% was notably below its grade 3 and grade 5 scores.
Results fell from 2024–2025, particularly in ELA: the two-school average dropped 18 points to 47%, while math fell 1 point to 70% and science fell 2 points to 58%. Even so, the latest combined averages remained above state averages by 3 points in ELA, 12 in math and 12 in science. SchoolDigger’s rankings also declined: Liberty moved from the 61st to the 55th percentile, and Valley Cottage from the 92nd to the 77th. As context, in 2024–2025 Valley Cottage had 384 students, a 10.4 student–teacher ratio and 26% free/reduced lunch eligible; Liberty had 452 students, an 11.5 ratio and 37% free/reduced lunch eligible. Both figures are for 2024–2025 and describe school differences, not what caused them.
Thank you for your feedback!