Summary:
ZIP code 10954 has five schools spanning kindergarten through grade 12: three elementary schools, one middle school and one high school, in the Nanuet Union Free School District and Clarkstown Central School District. The clearest overall pattern is that the supplied elementary and middle-school results are above state averages: by an average of 8 points in ELA, 9 points in math and 6 points in science. These averages describe grade-level results, not student-weighted outcomes, and do not mean every school or grade is above the state.
Bardonia Elementary School has the strongest shared elementary comparisons: it led Highview Elementary School by 10 points in grade 3 ELA and 15 points in grade 4 ELA, and by 5 points in grade 3 math; Highview led grade 4 math by 4 points. Bardonia was above the state in all five of its available ELA and math results, with leads ranging from 2 to 27 points. A MacArthur Barr Middle School was above the state in three of four math grades, including 14 points in grade 8, but grade 5 ELA was 5 points below. Nanuet Senior High School ranged from 96% proficient in Regents ELA, 19 points above the state, to 29% in Living Environment, 14 points below. George W Miller Elementary School serves K–2 and has no test scores in the supplied data; two Nanuet Regents results were also suppressed.
Results show meaningful year-to-year shifts, not a common trend across schools. MacArthur Barr grade 5 ELA fell 24 points from 2024–25 to 2025–26, while its grade 8 math rose 18 points; Nanuet’s Living Environment result dropped 55 points over those years. SchoolDigger’s percentile rankings also moved in different directions from 2023–24 to 2025–26: Nanuet fell from 89 to 79 and MacArthur Barr from 81 to 69, while Bardonia rose from 69 to 72 and Highview edged down from 70 to 69. As context, the schools’ 2024–25 free/reduced lunch eligible shares were similar at Bardonia (30%) and Highview (32%); student-teacher ratios were 10.3 and 12.4, respectively. Across all five schools, those shares ranged from 29% to 35%, and ratios from 9.4 to 12.4—useful details for comparing schools, but not explanations for test results.
Thank you for your feedback!