Summary:
Schools in zip code 10604 include three schools: two elementary schools serving kindergarten through grade 5 and Reach Academy, listed for grades 5–12. In 2025–2026, the two elementary schools’ averages were above state averages in English language arts (48% versus 44%), math (65% versus 58%) and grade 5 science (51% versus 45%). But those area averages hide the most important finding: results differ substantially between the two tested schools.
Samuel J Preston School stands out at the top: its average proficiency was 56% in ELA and 77% in math for grades 3–5, compared with 40% and 52% at George Washington School. Preston also led in grade 5 science, 67% to 35%. It scored above the state in all seven reported subject-grade results; George Washington did so in just two of seven. The widest gap was 32 percentage points in grade 5 science, followed by 25 points in the schools’ math averages. Reach Academy (The) has no test results in the data, so its performance cannot be compared.
Recent changes were mixed: the schools’ average ELA results fell 10 percentage points from the prior year, while their math average rose 5 points and science fell 3 points. Preston’s math gains in grades 3 and 4—25 and 8 points—came alongside a 10-point drop in grade 5 math and declines of 15 and 19 points in grade 4 and grade 5 ELA. SchoolDigger’s statewide rank percentile for George Washington rose from 22 to 41 between 2023–2024 and 2025–2026, even as its test-score changes varied. In 2024–2025, free/reduced lunch eligible students made up 47% at George Washington and 28% at Preston; their student-teacher ratios were 10.9 and 10.5, respectively. These school-level differences are context, not explanations for the score gap.
Thank you for your feedback!