Beta You're viewing our redesigned school page. Prefer the classic layout?

Bay Shore Middle School

Public Grades 6-8
990th
SchoolDigger Rank ?
of 1,500 New York Middle Schools
Better than 34% of New York middle schools
Summary

Bay Shore Middle School is a public middle school serving 1,269 students in grades 6-8 in the Bay Shore Union Free School District in Bay Shore, New York. While the school has consistently been ranked in the bottom half of New York middle schools, with a 2-star rating from SchoolDigger, there are some interesting insights that provide a more nuanced understanding of its performance.

Academically, Bay Shore Middle School's proficiency rates on state assessments tend to lag behind state and district averages, with 35.22% to 44.66% of students proficient or better in English Language Arts, and 30.51% to 60.38% proficient in math, compared to state averages of 50.86% to 52.38% and 50.86% to 52.38%, respectively. However, the school's students perform exceptionally well on Regents exams, with 100% proficiency rates in Algebra I and Earth Science, suggesting they are effectively preparing a subset of students for advanced coursework and college-level assessments. The school's performance also varies significantly across different student subgroups, with White and Multi-racial students performing relatively well, while English Language Learners, Low Socioeconomic Status students, and Female students have much lower rankings and proficiency rates.

Interestingly, the nearby schools, such as Candlewood Middle School, Beach Street Middle School, and East Islip Middle School, generally outperform Bay Shore Middle School on academic measures, with higher proficiency rates and better overall rankings. Additionally, Bay Shore Middle School has a relatively high percentage of students receiving free or reduced-price lunch, ranging from 54.31% to 57.13%, which is significantly higher than the nearby schools. While the school's per-student spending is higher than the state average, it is lower than some of the higher-performing nearby schools, suggesting that additional resources may be needed to address the unique challenges faced by the school's diverse student population.

1,258
Students ?
10.5
Student/teacher ratio ?
$32,573
Per pupil spending ?
43.3%
Free/discounted lunch ?
 393 Brook Ave
       Bay Shore, NY  11706-5646

(631) 968-1208

District: Bay Shore Union Free School District


Students who attend Bay Shore Middle School usually attend:

High:    Bay Shore Senior High School

Feeder schools for Bay Shore Middle School:

Elementary:    Brook Avenue Elementary School
    Fifth Avenue School
    Gardiner Manor School
    Mary G Clarkson School
    More...
Racial breakdown:

Hispanic:
52.2%
White:
23.5%
African American:
16.9%
more
 See top rated New York middle schools

 Compare Bay Shore Middle School to nearby middle schools!
At a glance
Ranking trend: Declining — 40th percentile in 2015 → 34th in 2025
Strengths
Small classes — about 10 students per teacher
Worth a look
!Ranking has slipped — down 6 percentile points since 2015
!English Language Arts scores 13 pts below the New York average
Students meeting standards (2024-2025) ?
This school56%
District avg54%
New York avg53%
990th of 1,500
New York public middle schools ?
Bottom 34%▼ down 6 pts since 2015
From bottom 40% (2015) to bottom 34% (2025)
See the entire ranking list of New York Middle Schools →
SchoolDigger rating ?
677th of 874Bay Shore Union Free School District among New York districts
Statewide rank percentile over time (100 = the top-ranked school in the state; click a legend item to add a student group)
Show full rank history (all student groups)

All Students

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew York percentileRating
202536.0990 of 150034.0%★★☆☆☆
202434.71022 of 150432.0%★★☆☆☆
202341.1904 of 150039.7%★★☆☆☆
202233.9997 of 147932.6%★★☆☆☆
202138.3774 of 124237.7%★★☆☆☆
201942.5778 of 143945.9%★★☆☆☆
201842.9815 of 143843.3%★★☆☆☆
201739.6871 of 145540.1%★★☆☆☆
201634.5955 of 142933.2%★★☆☆☆
201539.6849 of 140739.7%★★☆☆☆
201446.2734 of 140147.6%★★☆☆☆
201358.4519 of 137362.2%★★★☆☆
201273.2357 of 133773.3%★★★★☆
201172.5379 of 129570.7%★★★★☆
201070.7404 of 124367.5%★★★☆☆
200973.7329 of 122473.1%★★★★☆
200874.0330 of 118572.2%★★★★☆
200772.6324 of 112371.1%★★★★☆
200674.0289 of 109573.6%★★★★☆

African American

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew York percentileRating
202535.6458 of 67632.2%★★☆☆☆
202432.0510 of 70527.7%★☆☆☆☆
202338.8433 of 69637.8%★★☆☆☆
202235.8457 of 70635.3%★★☆☆☆
202151.0110 of 25356.5%★★★☆☆
201951.1257 of 65360.6%★★★☆☆
201841.6371 of 66344.0%★★☆☆☆

Asian

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew York percentileRating
202429.1317 of 39619.9%★☆☆☆☆
202217.9337 of 38111.5%★☆☆☆☆
201954.8186 of 36949.6%★★☆☆☆

English Language Learner

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew York percentileRating
202540.5351 of 64645.7%★★☆☆☆
202423.9582 of 6155.4%☆☆☆☆☆
202328.9490 of 59117.1%★☆☆☆☆
202226.9505 of 58113.1%★☆☆☆☆
201932.2351 of 47325.8%★☆☆☆☆
201835.3337 of 50333.0%★★☆☆☆

Female

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew York percentileRating
202534.41034 of 145729.0%★☆☆☆☆
202429.11102 of 146524.8%★☆☆☆☆
202337.9942 of 146335.6%★★☆☆☆
202234.4974 of 145433.0%★★☆☆☆
202130.2795 of 106625.4%★☆☆☆☆
201937.3879 of 137035.8%★★☆☆☆
201843.9784 of 135342.1%★★☆☆☆

Hispanic

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew York percentileRating
202535.6658 of 96531.8%★★☆☆☆
202436.3617 of 95335.3%★★☆☆☆
202336.8598 of 94336.6%★★☆☆☆
202232.1649 of 91429.0%★☆☆☆☆
202138.8271 of 44939.6%★★☆☆☆
201943.2435 of 82647.3%★★☆☆☆
201843.4453 of 81044.1%★★☆☆☆

Low Socio Economic Status

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew York percentileRating
202530.1958 of 128325.3%★☆☆☆☆
202428.7992 of 129623.5%★☆☆☆☆
202332.7937 of 128827.3%★☆☆☆☆
202226.11060 of 130618.8%★☆☆☆☆
202139.4550 of 93541.2%★★☆☆☆
201937.3748 of 124139.7%★★☆☆☆
201835.0833 of 124533.1%★★☆☆☆

Male

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew York percentileRating
202539.1890 of 145538.8%★★☆☆☆
202442.2825 of 146443.6%★★☆☆☆
202345.0784 of 146446.4%★★☆☆☆
202234.8960 of 145534.0%★★☆☆☆
202142.0612 of 107142.9%★★☆☆☆
201948.9624 of 136654.3%★★★☆☆
201842.7768 of 135243.2%★★☆☆☆

Multi-racial

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew York percentileRating
202455.691 of 22058.6%★★★☆☆

Special Education

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew York percentileRating
202548.6546 of 129857.9%★★★☆☆
202433.7863 of 130333.8%★★☆☆☆
202348.5544 of 130758.4%★★★☆☆
202235.3838 of 128334.7%★★☆☆☆
201935.9718 of 113937.0%★★☆☆☆
201828.7981 of 117016.2%★☆☆☆☆

White

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew York percentileRating
202557.9330 of 77557.4%★★★☆☆
202450.1386 of 77850.4%★★★☆☆
202368.4234 of 77269.7%★★★☆☆
202262.0261 of 74865.1%★★★☆☆
202164.1197 of 61467.9%★★★☆☆
201948.5367 of 71648.7%★★☆☆☆
201859.0316 of 76358.6%★★★☆☆
How student groups rank statewide ? (each group's percentile vs the same group at other schools — higher is better; the +/- beside each compares the group with this school's overall percentile)
Multi-racial (2024)59th percentile+27 vs school
Special Education (2025)58th percentile+24 vs school
White (2025)57th percentile+23 vs school
English Language Learner (2025)46th percentile+12 vs school
Male (2025)39th percentile+5 vs school
African American (2025)32nd percentile~ school
Hispanic (2025)32nd percentile~ school
Female (2025)29th percentile-5 vs school
Low Socio Economic Status (2025)25th percentile-9 vs school
Asian (2024)20th percentile-12 vs school
By subject vs New York (2024-2025) ?
Algebra I100%+44 vs state
Earth Science96%+31 vs state
Math47%-6 vs state
English Language Arts39%-13 vs state
Science37%-6 vs state

No ratings yet
Be the first to rate Bay Shore Middle School and help other families decide.
Rate Bay Shore Middle School
Have first-hand experience? A quick rating - and a sentence or two about what stands out (teachers, academics, safety, communication) - helps other families know what to expect.
Takes about a minute. We email you a link to verify your review - your address is never shown publicly.
Tap a star to rate
Reviews
No written reviews yet. If you know this school, be the first to share what stands out.



Schools Near Bay Shore Middle School









Frequently Asked Questions about Bay Shore Middle School

Bay Shore Middle School ranks 990th of 1500 New York middle schools. SchoolDigger rates this school 2 stars out of 5.

Students who attend Bay Shore Middle School usually go on to attend Bay Shore Senior High School

Students at Bay Shore Middle School are 52% Hispanic, 24% White, 17% African American, 4% Asian, 3% Two or more races.

In the 2024-25 school year, 1,258 students attended Bay Shore Middle School.


Rate Bay Shore Middle School!



Sign up for updates!

Be the first to know when there is an update for Bay Shore Middle School!




SchoolDigger data sources: National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education, the U.S. Census Bureau, the WNYC and the New York State Department of Health and the NY State Education Department.

IMPORTANT DISCLAIMERS: Not all boundaries are included. We make every effort to ensure that boundaries are up-to-date. But it's important to note that these are approximations and are for general informational purposes only. To verify legal descriptions of boundaries or school locations, contact your local tax assessor's office and/or school district.





Diagnostics

None retrieved from Database in 154 milliseconds.