Summary:
The three elementary schools in Valley Stream 24 Union Free School District, in Valley Stream, serve kindergarten through grade 6. In 2025–2026, their average grade 3–6 results were above state averages in English language arts (ELA) and math, but fifth-grade science was below the state rate; most importantly, the district-wide picture hides a substantial divide between schools.
William L Buck School stands out at the top: it led in all four math grades, three of four ELA grades, and fifth-grade science, with averages of 64% in ELA and 81% in math. Robert W Carbonaro School was also strong, averaging 57% in ELA and 75% in math and leading grade 4 ELA. At the other end, Brooklyn Avenue School averaged 38% in ELA and 49% in math. Buck’s averages were 26 percentage points higher than Brooklyn’s in ELA and 31 points higher in math. Brooklyn’s grade 6 results are a notable exception: 58% in ELA and 68% in math, both above state rates. Science also varied: Buck scored 55%, Carbonaro 39%, and Brooklyn 23%, compared with 45% statewide.
Results have shifted unevenly over time. From 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, the three-school averages fell by 8 points in ELA and 4 in math, while science fell by 8 points; the science average moved from 2 points above the state to 6 points below it. Buck was the only school whose math average rose, gaining 3 points, while Brooklyn had the largest declines in both ELA and math. SchoolDigger’s statewide percentile ranking rose from 72 to 76 for Carbonaro, slipped from 87 to 85 for Buck, and dropped from 57 to 35 for Brooklyn. As additional context, 2024–2025 student-teacher ratios were 10.3 at Carbonaro, 10.7 at Brooklyn, and 12.5 at Buck. The reported free/reduced lunch eligible measure for 2024–2025 was 35% at Carbonaro, 48% at Brooklyn, and 36% at Buck; these figures describe the schools, but do not explain their results.
Thank you for your feedback!