Summary:
ZIP code 08854 has 15 schools: seven elementary, three middle, two high schools and three alternative schools, covering elementary through high school grades as well as alternative programs. Among the 11 schools with reported test scores, achievement varies considerably by grade and subject: the four grade 3 schools average 46% in English language arts (ELA), below the state’s 48%, but 51% in mathematics, above the state’s 49%. The most important takeaway is that a ZIP-code-wide picture hides substantial differences between individual schools and subjects.
Conackamack Middle School is the clearest middle-school strength: it leads in ELA in grades 6, 7 and 8, scoring 63%, 65% and 75%, respectively, compared with state results of 51%, 56% and 53%. Martin Luther King Elementary School leads its grade 4–5 peer, Arbor Elementary School, in all five reported subject comparisons and is above the state in each. In grade 3, Randolphville Elementary School leads ELA at 56%, while Knollwood Elementary School leads mathematics at 63%; both are above state results. At the lower end, Dwight D. Eisenhower Elementary School scores 37% in grade 3 ELA and 38% in mathematics, below the state in both. Grade 8 mathematics is a broader concern: results at Theodore Schor Middle School, Quibbletown Middle School and Conackamack range from 6% to 13%, all below the state’s 23%.
Recent changes are mixed rather than uniformly upward: the average elementary school-versus-state margin across the same 18 comparisons narrowed from 5 percentage points in 2024–2025 to 3 points in 2025–2026. Randolphville’s grade 3 ELA rose 4 points while its mathematics fell 6; Grandview Elementary School and Knollwood also declined in SchoolDigger’s rankings, from the 50th to 39th percentile and 82nd to 64th, respectively. Measures provide context, not explanations: 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible shares ranged from 33% at Knollwood to 65% at Piscataway Magnet School; Randolphville’s student-teacher ratio was 16.2, compared with Grandview’s 6.3. Magnet’s results also vary by test: it was below state in several measures but reached 81% in grade 11 NJGPA ELA, above the state’s 76%.
Thank you for your feedback!