Summary:
ZIP code 07751 has four schools: two elementary schools serving K–5, one middle school serving grades 6–8, and the David C Abbott Early Learning Center, serving PK–K; the three tested schools have results, while Abbott does not. In 2025–2026, the elementary schools’ matched-grade averages were 74% in ELA, 75% in math, and 52% in grade 5 science; Marlboro Memorial Middle School averaged 73% in ELA, 56% in math, and 42% in grade 8 science. Most importantly, all three tested schools were above state averages in every listed grade-level subject, with school averages ahead by 20–28 points in ELA and math and 23–24 points in science.
No elementary school leads across every grade and subject. Asher Holmes Elementary School leads grade 5 ELA and math, scoring 79% and 81%, while Robertsville Elementary School leads grade 4 ELA and math at 76% and 79%, and grade 5 science at 53%. The biggest elementary gap is grade 5 math: Asher is ahead by 9 points; their grade 3 ELA results differ by just 1 point. Marlboro Memorial has no same-grade peer in this list; its grade 8 math is its lowest listed core result at 43%, but still 21 points above the state. SchoolDigger ranks all three tested schools in the 90th–91st percentile statewide.
Recent score changes vary by school: from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026, Asher’s listed results rose by an average of 1 point, Robertsville’s fell by 3 points, and Marlboro Memorial’s were nearly unchanged; Marlboro’s grade 8 science score rose by 9 points. SchoolDigger’s percentile rankings stayed at 91st for Marlboro, moved from 92nd to 91st for Asher, and rose from 89th to 90th for Robertsville over the three reported years. Chronic absenteeism is a concern to weigh alongside Marlboro’s test results: in 2024–2025 it was 17%, versus 10% districtwide and 14% statewide; the two elementary schools were each at 6%. All four schools report the same low-income measure, free/reduced lunch eligible, for 2024–2025: 13% at Asher, 14% at Robertsville, 15% at Marlboro, and 11% at Abbott. These figures are context, not an explanation for score differences.
Thank you for your feedback!