Summary:
ZIP code 07481 has five public schools in Wyckoff Township Public School District: four elementary schools serving kindergarten through grade 5 (with Sicomac also serving pre-K) and one middle school serving grades 6–8. In 2025–26, every school’s grade-average ELA and math results were above the matched state averages. The most important distinction for families is that strong state comparisons still mask meaningful differences among local schools, especially in elementary results.
Calvin Coolidge and Abraham Lincoln lead the elementary schools, with Coolidge averaging 73% in ELA and Lincoln 72%; Lincoln narrowly leads math, 70.8% to Coolidge’s 70.7%. George Washington is also strong, averaging 70% in ELA and 65% in math. Sicomac is the lowest of the four in both subjects, at 58% in ELA and 59% in math, though still above state averages of 49% and 47%. Science results vary more: Coolidge’s fifth-grade score is 54%, while Sicomac’s is 20%, below the state’s 27%. Dwight D. Eisenhower, the area’s only middle school, averages 69% in ELA and 56% in math, both above state results.
Recent changes point in different directions: Sicomac’s averages fell 7 percentage points in ELA and 11 in math, while Lincoln improved 4 points in ELA and 2 in math; Coolidge’s ELA average declined 14 points. SchoolDigger rankings also shifted: Sicomac moved from 311th of 1,347 schools to 515th of 1,331, while Lincoln rose from 293rd to 214th. Staffing ratios offer context, not a clear explanation: elementary schools range from 11.5 students per teacher at Coolidge to 13.4 at Sicomac. Both Sicomac and Lincoln reported similar free/reduced lunch eligible measures for school year 2024–25—0.8% and 0.9%—despite substantially different test averages.
Thank you for your feedback!