Summary:
ZIP code 07040 has six schools in the South Orange-Maplewood School District: four elementary schools serving grades K–5, one middle school serving grades 6–8, and one high school serving grades 9–12. The strongest shared pattern is in elementary results: in 2025–2026, the four-school average was above state averages in ELA, math, and grade 5 science. The clearest standout is Tuscan Elementary School, which led most elementary comparisons.
Tuscan led all four elementary schools in ELA grades 3–5, math grades 4–5, and grade 5 science; its ELA results ranged from 78% to 89%, compared with state rates of 46% to 52%. Clinton Elementary School narrowly led grade 3 math, at 75.0% versus Tuscan’s 74.8%. The lowest results varied by grade: Seth Boyden Elementary Demonstration School was lowest in grade 3 ELA and grade 3 and 5 math, while Delia Bolden Elementary School was lowest in grade 4 ELA and math and grade 5 science. Bolden’s grade 4 math, 42%, was the only elementary result below the state rate. At the secondary level, Maplewood Middle School was above state ELA rates in grades 6–8 but below state math rates in grades 7–8. Columbia High School was above state rates on several reported tests, but Algebra II was a notable weakness: 16% for grade 9 and 15% for End of Course, against state rates of 53% and 52%.
The elementary group’s advantage over the state widened from 2024–2025 to 2025–2026: by 6 points in ELA, 4 in math, and 5 in grade 5 science. SchoolDigger’s percentile rankings also rose from 2023–2024 to 2025–2026 at five schools, including a 23-point increase for Seth Boyden and an 8-point rise for Tuscan; Bolden fell 14 points, while Columbia and Maplewood Middle each rose 10. As context, 2024–2025 free/reduced lunch eligible rates ranged from 7% at Tuscan to 23% at Clinton; the reported student-teacher ratios ranged from 9.1 at Seth Boyden to 14.2 at Columbia. These measures describe school context, not the cause of results; secondary schools are each the only local school of their level in this list.
Thank you for your feedback!