Beta You're viewing our redesigned school page. Prefer the classic layout?

Old Mill Elementary School

Public Grades K-5
222nd
SchoolDigger Rank ?
of 1,331 New Jersey Elementary Schools
Better than 83% of New Jersey elementary schools
Summary

Old Mill Elementary School in Sea Girt, New Jersey, serves 396 students in kindergarten through fifth grade in a coastal community with several nearby elementary schools. Its latest results are above state proficiency rates in every reported subject, but the most important finding for parents is the variation by grade: strong fifth-grade ELA and third-grade math results sit alongside a clear fourth-grade math weakness.

Across grades 3–5, Old Mill averaged 72% in ELA and 69% in math, compared with 49% and 47% statewide and 69% and 66% in the Wall Township Public School District. Fifth-grade ELA is a standout: 80% proficiency ranked second among 10 nearby schools with reported results; only Allenwood Elementary School scored higher, at 80.3%. Old Mill’s third- and fifth-grade math results each ranked third among 10 nearby schools. Fourth-grade math, by contrast, ranked ninth among 11: its 54% was 10 points below the district, though 7 points above the state. Fifth-grade science was also above both the district and state, at 46% versus 41% and 27%.

Results have improved overall since 2022–23: the ELA average rose 11 points to 72%, math rose 4 points to 69%, and fifth-grade science rose 3 points to 46%, despite year-to-year fluctuation. SchoolDigger’s statewide percentile increased from 74 to 83, including a 5-point rise in the latest year; the school is ranked 222nd of 1,331 schools and has 4 stars. Its 2024–25 student-teacher ratio was 9, and 6% of students were free/reduced lunch eligible that year; these are context, not explanations for test results. Chronic absenteeism rose from 5.5% to 9.8% in the latest year, still below the district’s 10.3% and state’s 14.4%. SchoolDigger’s effectiveness measure also shifted for student groups: the female-student percentile fell from 97 to 78 between 2023–24 and 2025–26, while the male-student percentile rose from 71 to 88.

396
Students ?
9.0
Student/teacher ratio ?
$12,444
Per pupil spending ?
6.3%
Free/reduced lunch eligible (2024-25) ?
 2119 Old Mill Road
       Sea Girt, NJ  08750-1199

(732) 556-2140

District: Wall Township Public School District


Students who attend Old Mill Elementary School usually attend:

Middle:    Wall Intermediate School
High:    Wall High School
Racial breakdown:

White:
86.1%
Hispanic:
8.8%
Two or more races:
4.3%
more
 See top rated New Jersey elementary schools

 Compare Old Mill Elementary School to nearby elementary schools!
At a glance
▲ Ranking trend: Improving — 65th percentile in 2016 → 83rd in 2026
Strengths
✓Test scores above the New Jersey average (67% vs 45% meeting standards)
✓Ranks in the top 17% of New Jersey elementary schools
✓Ranking is trending up — up 18 percentile points since 2016
Students meeting standards (2025-2026) ?
This school67%
District avg64%
New Jersey avg45%
222nd of 1,331
New Jersey public elementary schools ?
Top 17%▲ up 19 pts since 2016
From top 35% (2016) to top 17% (2026)
See the entire ranking list of New Jersey Elementary Schools →
★★★★★
SchoolDigger rating ?
2nd of 4Elementary Schools in the Wall Township Public School District
125th of 607Wall Township Public School District among New Jersey districts
Statewide rank percentile over time (100 = the top-ranked school in the state; click a legend item to add a student group)
Show full rank history (all student groups)

All Students

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew Jersey percentileRating
202683.7222 of 133183.3%★★★★☆
202579.0303 of 134777.5%★★★★☆
202477.7312 of 133876.7%★★★★☆
202375.3353 of 134273.7%★★★★☆
202277.3328 of 134575.6%★★★★☆
202180.6215 of 131783.7%★★★★☆
201978.7292 of 136078.5%★★★★☆
201871.0442 of 135367.3%★★★☆☆
201776.4345 of 135274.5%★★★★☆
201667.5474 of 134664.8%★★★☆☆
201579.3281 of 135779.3%★★★★☆
201477.4306 of 136377.5%★★★★☆
201375.8346 of 136774.7%★★★★☆
201273.9400 of 136370.7%★★★★☆
201179.2237 of 136082.6%★★★★☆
201079.6217 of 135484.0%★★★★☆
200974.2355 of 134673.6%★★★★☆
200868.8497 of 133862.9%★★★☆☆
200767.0551 of 132958.5%★★★☆☆
200676.0312 of 131476.3%★★★★☆
200578.2225 of 130382.7%★★★★☆
200474.4343 of 129873.6%★★★★☆
200378.9249 of 120479.3%★★★★☆

Female

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew Jersey percentileRating
202678.2284 of 131178.3%★★★★☆
202579.8263 of 132680.2%★★★★☆
202494.235 of 131797.3%★★★★★
202372.6373 of 131871.7%★★★★☆
202275.1342 of 132674.2%★★★★☆
202172.7284 of 129078.0%★★★★☆
201974.9330 of 133175.2%★★★★☆
201868.2456 of 133365.8%★★★☆☆

Male

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew Jersey percentileRating
202685.8160 of 130687.7%★★★★☆
202574.3340 of 131874.2%★★★★☆
202471.0377 of 131371.3%★★★★☆
202376.7299 of 131577.3%★★★★☆
202277.2296 of 132477.6%★★★★☆
202183.3182 of 129786.0%★★★★☆
201979.7244 of 133581.7%★★★★☆
201870.7410 of 133469.3%★★★☆☆

Special Education

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew Jersey percentileRating
202671.4223 of 97077.0%★★★★☆
202571.8225 of 102378.0%★★★★☆
202456.6341 of 98965.5%★★★☆☆
202362.4272 of 95871.6%★★★★☆
202267.8236 of 94975.1%★★★★☆
202149.0370 of 86857.4%★★★☆☆
201986.795 of 100790.6%★★★★★
201840.0536 of 100146.5%★★☆☆☆

White

YearAvg scoreStatewide rankNew Jersey percentileRating
202676.4187 of 95180.3%★★★★☆
202569.3283 of 97070.8%★★★★☆
202468.5278 of 96371.1%★★★★☆
202364.4329 of 97566.3%★★★☆☆
202270.6273 of 97672.0%★★★★☆
202173.0198 of 96479.5%★★★★☆
201969.0288 of 102371.8%★★★★☆
201855.4483 of 102252.7%★★★☆☆
How student groups rank statewide ? (each group's percentile vs the same group at other schools — higher is better; the +/- beside each compares the group with this school's overall percentile)
Male (2026)88th percentile+4 vs school
White (2026)80th percentile-3 vs school
Female (2026)78th percentile-5 vs school
Special Education (2026)77th percentile-6 vs school
By subject vs New Jersey (2025-2026) ?
English Language Arts72%+24 vs state
Mathematics68%+21 vs state
Science46%+19 vs state

★
No ratings yet
Be the first to rate Old Mill Elementary School and help other families decide.
Rate Old Mill Elementary School
Have first-hand experience? A quick rating - and a sentence or two about what stands out (teachers, academics, safety, communication) - helps other families know what to expect.
Takes about a minute. We email you a link to verify your review - your address is never shown publicly.
Tap a star to rate
Reviews
No written reviews yet. If you know this school, be the first to share what stands out.



Schools Near Old Mill Elementary School

Sort
Ranking:
Map legend
E Elementary M Middle H High A Alternative P Private






Frequently Asked Questions about Old Mill Elementary School

Old Mill Elementary School ranks 222nd of 1331 New Jersey elementary schools. SchoolDigger rates this school 4 stars out of 5.

Students at Old Mill Elementary School are 86% White, 9% Hispanic, 4% Two or more races.

In the 2024-25 school year, 396 students attended Old Mill Elementary School.

Students who attend Old Mill Elementary School usually go on to attend:

Middle : Wall Intermediate School
High : Wall High School

Rate Old Mill Elementary School!



Sign up for updates!

Be the first to know when there is an update for Old Mill Elementary School!


Latest New Jersey data All new data »
2023–24 NJSLA test scoresNewNov 13, 2026
2025–26 NJGPA, NJSLA & NJSLA-S test scoresNewNov 4, 2026
2019–20 through 2024–25 school spending dataOct 6, 2026
2024–25 attendance data, dropout rates & graduation ratesJun 13, 2026


SchoolDigger data sources: National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education, the U.S. Census Bureau and the New Jersey Department of Education.

IMPORTANT DISCLAIMERS: Not all boundaries are included. We make every effort to ensure that boundaries are up-to-date. But it's important to note that these are approximations and are for general informational purposes only. To verify legal descriptions of boundaries or school locations, contact your local tax assessor's office and/or school district.

Diagnostics